S05E05 — aired 2004-04-04

Irregular Around the Margins

Season 5 episode guide — plot, credits, music, and analysis.

Plot

The season opens on a somber note as Tony Soprano is laid to rest at the funeral home, marking a significant shift in the family's dynamic as he enters a new chapter of his life. The narrative quickly pivots to the aftermath of the previous season's chaotic events, focusing on the fallout involving Christopher Moltisanti and the tension surrounding A.J.'s recent behavior. Tony attempts to maintain control over his family empire while grappling with the lingering effects of his own psychological struggles. A major thread involves the ongoing conflict between Tony and Livia, which has escalated into a full-blown feud that threatens to consume everyone in the family circle. Livia's influence continues to seep into Tony's life through phone calls and visits from her associates, creating a palpable sense of dread and anxiety within the Soprano household. Meanwhile, Christopher finds himself in a precarious position as he tries to navigate the treacherous waters of organized crime without getting caught or making a fatal mistake. The episode delves deep into the personal lives of the core cast, exploring themes of loyalty, betrayal, and the relentless pressure of maintaining power in an unforgiving world. Tony's relationship with Carmela is tested as they face external pressures that strain their marriage to breaking point. Additionally, the episode highlights the complexities of family dynamics, showing how each member copes with stress in their own unique way, often leading to unexpected outcomes and emotional outbursts. Throughout the storyline, we see glimpses of the broader criminal underworld, where alliances are forged and broken with equal ease. The presence of rival gangs and internal disputes adds layers of tension that keep viewers on edge. As Tony tries to balance his roles as a father, husband, and mob boss, he often finds himself at odds with his own instincts, leading to moments of introspection and doubt about the path he has chosen. The episode concludes with a mix of resolution and open-ended questions, leaving audiences wondering about the future direction of the series and what challenges lie ahead for our favorite characters. It serves as both a continuation of the overarching narrative and a standalone exploration of the human condition under extreme circumstances.

Credits

Executive Producers: David Chase, Robin Green, Mitchell Burgess Creators: David Chase Director: Tim Van Patten Writers: Robin Green, Mitchell Burgess Starring: James Gandolfini as Tony Soprano, Edie Falco as Carmela Soprano, Michael Imperioli as Christopher Moltisanti, Lorraine Bracco as Dr. Jennifer Melfi, Amy Adams as Patty Hewes (uncredited), and Jamie-Lynn Sigler as A.J. Soprano.

Music

"Blackbird - The Beatles" "Come Together - The Beatles" "Here Comes The Sun - The Beatles" "Don't Let Me Down - Wings" "Let It Be - The Beatles"

Analysis

From a fan's perspective, this episode stands out as a pivotal moment in the series, pushing boundaries while maintaining the show's core themes. The writers, Robin Green and Mitchell Burgess, have crafted a narrative that feels both intimate and expansive, capturing the essence of what makes The Sopranos so compelling. Their background in psychology shines through in the nuanced portrayal of Tony's internal conflicts, adding depth to his character arc. One of the most talked-about aspects of this episode is Tony's decision to use drugs for the first time on-screen, a moment that shocked many longtime fans. While some may argue it stretches his character, it serves as a metaphorical representation of the chaotic forces at play in his life. It's a bold choice by the writers, signaling a turning point in Tony's journey and raising questions about his ability to maintain control over his own destiny. Christopher's volatile nature continues to be a highlight, with scenes like his outburst in Dover adding humor and tension in equal measure. His character remains one of the most dynamic on the show, constantly oscillating between loyalty and self-preservation. The way he interacts with others, especially when pushed to his limits, provides some of the funniest moments in the series, reminding us why we love him despite his flaws. The episode also tackles heavy themes like family dysfunction and the impact of generational trauma, particularly through A.J.'s storyline. His struggles with identity and belonging reflect broader issues faced by many young people today, making the show relevant beyond its criminal context. The way these personal stories intersect with the larger plot creates a rich tapestry of human experiences that keeps viewers engaged. Overall, this episode is a testament to the show's ability to evolve while staying true to its roots. It challenges expectations and pushes the narrative forward in ways that are both surprising and satisfying. As fans, we appreciate the courage it takes to take risks like this, knowing that not every decision will land perfectly. Yet, those risks often lead to some of the most memorable moments in television history. For those eager to revisit these iconic scenes or catch up on the series, you can find where to watch here: where to watch.